To Refresh or Not to Refresh

I’m in a bit of a quandary. I’ve wanted to refresh the book covers for the THREE STRAND CORD Series for a while now. I still love the original covers but trends change. When I took a cover design course recently, it solidified my sense that this was the right move.

HOWEVER, now that I have options, I feel conflicted!  What’s a girl to do?

Ask for help, of course! Below are three new refreshed and more “on trend” covers for each book in the series. Below that are the originals.

My question: Should I change the covers on all the ebooks or not? (I won’t do anything with the paperbacks until there’s some proof that the new covers convert better.)

I’d love some feedback to help me make a decision. Just pop your “Yes” or “No” in the comments. You can expand on your reasons if you want to (optimal) but it isn’t necessary! Thanks in advance!

NEW!

ORIGINAL!